The Fall And Rise Of CMA Merger Remedies

I’ve talked in recent posts (here, here and here) about the noticeable rise in CMA merger remedies, both at Phase 1 and Phase 2.

Here’s the overall picture…..

For most of the CMA’s existence the number investigations each year that conclude with competition problems being dealt with by remedies has been between four and ten.

Since last summer, however, there’s been a noticeable increase beyond the normal range – especially noticeable given that the number of public merger investigations has fallen to record low levels.

The rise in remedies seems strong but the chart helps keep things in perspective.

First, the recent number of remedy outcomes, while striking, is not unprecedented.

And, second, the number of remedies has risen and fallen several times. Short-term ‘trends’ have a habit of disappearing.

Even so, an interesting question is whether we have yet to reach ‘peak remedy’ this time around, especially given the changes to the CMA’s remedy processes that I noted in a previous post.

Other interesting ‘remedy’ topics include

  • how the pattern compares with that for merger prohibitions
  • the extent to which the greater use of remedies deters companies from proceeding with deals that may harm competition or chills transactions that might benefit competition.

Which remedy topics would you, dear reader, like to know more about? Do feel free to leave a comment or to drop me a line.

I’m expecting to say more about merger remedies in future posts. Do feel free to click the ‘follow’ button at the side of the main blog page to subscribe to the blog series.

Notes on the above chart:

For each period of 12 months the graph tracks the number of final merger decisions in that period that have been remedy outcomes. Cases are taken into account in the 12 months in which the final decision for the case is published. A Phase 1 case therefore appears in the series when the full written decision is published, unless it is referred to Phase 2, in which case it appears in the series when the full Phase 2 decision is published or the case is abandoned by the merging parties.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s